Name: Towards AI
Legal Name: Towards AI, Inc.
Description: Towards AI is the world's leading artificial intelligence (AI) and technology publication. Read by thought-leaders and decision-makers around the world.
Phone Number: +1-650-246-9381
Email: pub@towardsai.net
228 Park Avenue SouthNew York,
NY10003United States
Name: Towards AI
Legal Name: Towards AI, Inc.
Description: Towards AI is the world's leading artificial intelligence (AI) and technology publication.
Founders:
Roberto Iriondo,
Website,
Job Title: Co-founder and Advisor
Works for: Towards AI, Inc.
Follow Roberto:
X,
LinkedIn,
GitHub,
Google Scholar,
Towards AI Profile,
Medium,
ML@CMU,
FreeCodeCamp,
Crunchbase,
Bloomberg,
Roberto Iriondo, Generative AI Lab,
Generative AI LabDenis Piffaretti,
Job Title: Co-founder
Works for: Towards AI, Inc.Louie Peters,
Job Title: Co-founder
Works for: Towards AI, Inc.Louis-François Bouchard,
Job Title: Co-founder
Works for: Towards AI, Inc.
Cover:
Logo:
Areas Served: Worldwide
Alternate Name: Towards AI, Inc.
Alternate Name: Towards AI Co.
Alternate Name: towards ai
Alternate Name: towardsai
Alternate Name: towards.ai
Alternate Name: tai
Alternate Name: toward ai
Alternate Name: toward.ai
Alternate Name: Towards AI, Inc.
Alternate Name: towardsai.net
Alternate Name: pub.towardsai.net
Mixed Models are a great tool for estimating variance components and using those estimates to provide predictions. The predictions coming from Mixed Models are called Best Linear Unbiased Prediction(BLUP), and they are called that way because they include the fixed and random effects of the model to provide a prediction.
By including both fixed and random effects, Mixed Models allow a technique called ‘shrinkage’, or partial-pooling, which limits the potential for overfitting. In short, when a Mixed Model is made, the fixed effect is estimated across all observations, but the random part is done per level.
So, if you have observations across time for 100 people, you could ask the model to estimate different intercepts and different slopes (trajectories) for each of those 100 people. Now, you have multiple modeling options:
You fit a linear regression model on all the observations. This is called a pooled model since no people-level trajectories are estimated. Just one single intercept and one single slope.
You fit a linear regression model on each observation, separately. Now, you have estimated 100 intercepts and 100 slopes, separately, per person. This is the equivalent of splitting the dataset up in 100 parts. None of the people know the other 99 exist.
You fit a mixed model. The fixed intercept and slope effect are global, but you also estimate a person-dependent intercept and slope. To realize such feet, there needs to be enough variance in both the start and the trajectory of the curve. The way the random parts are estimated is called partial-pooling since the form follows a Normal distribution[0, variance]. Here, each specific random effect is determined by the population effect and person-specific deviance. To counter overfitting, the estimates furthest away from the population average are shrunk back the most to zero, since we believe they are more like anomalies. If we would not do so, the variance estimate of the random effect would explode.
Now, in this example, using SAS, I will show you how I compared pooled, no-pooled, and various partially pooled models on a dataset containing the semen volume of 129 boars measured at 4 time points.
Let’s load in the data and visualize.I am looking for sufficient variation to warrant estimating random effects.Lets start with an un-pooled quadratic model.The plots clearly show how the observations to the left are closely followed by the predictions. Such a model is dangerously close to overfitting, although standard statistics like R-squared will disagree. To these statistics, an un-pooled model will eagerly follow observations and thus fit very closely.Code for the pooled model.The pooled model makes a pooled estimate. To this model, the variation is just unexplained variation. You can expect the standard errors of the intercept, slope, and quadratic slope to have exploded.Before running a mixed model, you can take a look to see if the boar-specific estimates from the un-pooled model deviate from the estimates of the pooled model. This is NOT a substitute for a Mixed Model. No partial-pooling took place here.The intercept and slope for sure hint at deviances from the population mean. The quadratic slope does not seem to shift that much at the boar level. Hence, this graph hints at a random-intercept-random-slope-model.Lets look at different estimates by different random models. You see an un-pooled model, a random intercept, a random-intercept-random-slope, and a random-intercept-random-slopes model. The latter meaning that I want to see if both the linear and quadratic slope differs on a boar level.The intercept model seems to show a high fluctuation across the population mean in both the un-pooled and the mixed model. The mixed model does not really recognize variance in the slope, which in contrast with the un-pooled model. In general, a mixed model is way more sophisticated tool to pick up any necessity for a random component.Code to run five types of models.Global Fixed and Random effects for each of the five types of models. As you can see, the last model would not converge. No statistical tests for random effects should be used. Instead use graphs, like below.The graph to the left shows what each model brings to the tabel. Although they tend to predict well, overall, their limits differ substantially based on what was included. The low confidence and prediction limits of the pooled model are paradoxical unless you realize that the mode were asked to estimate population means. The pooled model is made for that. To the right, you can clearly see how each model ‘thinks’. The un-pooled model provided boar-specific fixed estimates, whereas the pooled model only provides a global estimate. The random-intercept and random-intercept-month both provide shrunk predictions. It can be clearly seen that they do not fall for the extreme observations. Hence, limiting overfitting by shrinkage.Boar-specific estimates coming from the un-pooled and mixed models. The graphs are a bit difficult to compare due to changing axes, but they depict the same data showing a substantial amount of variation at the intercept, but less at the slope. They also show the shrinkage applied at the boar-specific intercepts — confidence limits are much smaller in the mixed model than in the un-pooled model.
Below you can see some additional pieces of code added to look deeper into specific Mixed Models created. They are not easy to use and often lead to non-convergence or matrices that are not positive definitive. If such a warning should arise, you need to simplify the model.
These plots show if the normality assumption of the random effects is met, where it makes sense to include a random effect, and how often estimates within a random effect vary. The latter part will give you a nice hint at the level of shrinkage applied.I always like to look at the predictions provided by a mixed model for each of the levels included in the dataset — here, this would be: total, month, animal. As you can see in the animal-level predictions, the marginal prediction (green line) is no good.
I hope this post gave you a bit more feeling about what BLUPs are and shrinkage does. Please reach out to me if you have questions, ideas, or just want to spar!
Join thousands of data leaders on the AI newsletter. Join over 80,000 subscribers and keep up to date with the latest developments in AI. From research to projects and ideas. If you are building an AI startup, an AI-related product, or a service, we invite you to consider becoming a sponsor.
`;
} else {
console.error('Element with id="subscribe" not found within the page with class "home".');
}
}
});
// Remove duplicate text from articles
/* Backup: 09/11/24
function removeDuplicateText() {
const elements = document.querySelectorAll('h1, h2, h3, h4, h5, strong'); // Select the desired elements
const seenTexts = new Set(); // A set to keep track of seen texts
const tagCounters = {}; // Object to track instances of each tag
elements.forEach(el => {
const tagName = el.tagName.toLowerCase(); // Get the tag name (e.g., 'h1', 'h2', etc.)
// Initialize a counter for each tag if not already done
if (!tagCounters[tagName]) {
tagCounters[tagName] = 0;
}
// Only process the first 10 elements of each tag type
if (tagCounters[tagName] >= 2) {
return; // Skip if the number of elements exceeds 10
}
const text = el.textContent.trim(); // Get the text content
const words = text.split(/\s+/); // Split the text into words
if (words.length >= 4) { // Ensure at least 4 words
const significantPart = words.slice(0, 5).join(' '); // Get first 5 words for matching
// Check if the text (not the tag) has been seen before
if (seenTexts.has(significantPart)) {
// console.log('Duplicate found, removing:', el); // Log duplicate
el.remove(); // Remove duplicate element
} else {
seenTexts.add(significantPart); // Add the text to the set
}
}
tagCounters[tagName]++; // Increment the counter for this tag
});
}
removeDuplicateText();
*/
// Remove duplicate text from articles
function removeDuplicateText() {
const elements = document.querySelectorAll('h1, h2, h3, h4, h5, strong'); // Select the desired elements
const seenTexts = new Set(); // A set to keep track of seen texts
const tagCounters = {}; // Object to track instances of each tag
// List of classes to be excluded
const excludedClasses = ['medium-author', 'post-widget-title'];
elements.forEach(el => {
// Skip elements with any of the excluded classes
if (excludedClasses.some(cls => el.classList.contains(cls))) {
return; // Skip this element if it has any of the excluded classes
}
const tagName = el.tagName.toLowerCase(); // Get the tag name (e.g., 'h1', 'h2', etc.)
// Initialize a counter for each tag if not already done
if (!tagCounters[tagName]) {
tagCounters[tagName] = 0;
}
// Only process the first 10 elements of each tag type
if (tagCounters[tagName] >= 10) {
return; // Skip if the number of elements exceeds 10
}
const text = el.textContent.trim(); // Get the text content
const words = text.split(/\s+/); // Split the text into words
if (words.length >= 4) { // Ensure at least 4 words
const significantPart = words.slice(0, 5).join(' '); // Get first 5 words for matching
// Check if the text (not the tag) has been seen before
if (seenTexts.has(significantPart)) {
// console.log('Duplicate found, removing:', el); // Log duplicate
el.remove(); // Remove duplicate element
} else {
seenTexts.add(significantPart); // Add the text to the set
}
}
tagCounters[tagName]++; // Increment the counter for this tag
});
}
removeDuplicateText();
//Remove unnecessary text in blog excerpts
document.querySelectorAll('.blog p').forEach(function(paragraph) {
// Replace the unwanted text pattern for each paragraph
paragraph.innerHTML = paragraph.innerHTML
.replace(/Author\(s\): [\w\s]+ Originally published on Towards AI\.?/g, '') // Removes 'Author(s): XYZ Originally published on Towards AI'
.replace(/This member-only story is on us\. Upgrade to access all of Medium\./g, ''); // Removes 'This member-only story...'
});
//Load ionic icons and cache them
if ('localStorage' in window && window['localStorage'] !== null) {
const cssLink = 'https://code.ionicframework.com/ionicons/2.0.1/css/ionicons.min.css';
const storedCss = localStorage.getItem('ionicons');
if (storedCss) {
loadCSS(storedCss);
} else {
fetch(cssLink).then(response => response.text()).then(css => {
localStorage.setItem('ionicons', css);
loadCSS(css);
});
}
}
function loadCSS(css) {
const style = document.createElement('style');
style.innerHTML = css;
document.head.appendChild(style);
}
//Remove elements from imported content automatically
function removeStrongFromHeadings() {
const elements = document.querySelectorAll('h1, h2, h3, h4, h5, h6, span');
elements.forEach(el => {
const strongTags = el.querySelectorAll('strong');
strongTags.forEach(strongTag => {
while (strongTag.firstChild) {
strongTag.parentNode.insertBefore(strongTag.firstChild, strongTag);
}
strongTag.remove();
});
});
}
removeStrongFromHeadings();
"use strict";
window.onload = () => {
/*
//This is an object for each category of subjects and in that there are kewords and link to the keywods
let keywordsAndLinks = {
//you can add more categories and define their keywords and add a link
ds: {
keywords: [
//you can add more keywords here they are detected and replaced with achor tag automatically
'data science',
'Data science',
'Data Science',
'data Science',
'DATA SCIENCE',
],
//we will replace the linktext with the keyword later on in the code
//you can easily change links for each category here
//(include class="ml-link" and linktext)
link: 'linktext',
},
ml: {
keywords: [
//Add more keywords
'machine learning',
'Machine learning',
'Machine Learning',
'machine Learning',
'MACHINE LEARNING',
],
//Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext)
link: 'linktext',
},
ai: {
keywords: [
'artificial intelligence',
'Artificial intelligence',
'Artificial Intelligence',
'artificial Intelligence',
'ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE',
],
//Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext)
link: 'linktext',
},
nl: {
keywords: [
'NLP',
'nlp',
'natural language processing',
'Natural Language Processing',
'NATURAL LANGUAGE PROCESSING',
],
//Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext)
link: 'linktext',
},
des: {
keywords: [
'data engineering services',
'Data Engineering Services',
'DATA ENGINEERING SERVICES',
],
//Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext)
link: 'linktext',
},
td: {
keywords: [
'training data',
'Training Data',
'training Data',
'TRAINING DATA',
],
//Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext)
link: 'linktext',
},
ias: {
keywords: [
'image annotation services',
'Image annotation services',
'image Annotation services',
'image annotation Services',
'Image Annotation Services',
'IMAGE ANNOTATION SERVICES',
],
//Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext)
link: 'linktext',
},
l: {
keywords: [
'labeling',
'labelling',
],
//Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext)
link: 'linktext',
},
pbp: {
keywords: [
'previous blog posts',
'previous blog post',
'latest',
],
//Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext)
link: 'linktext',
},
mlc: {
keywords: [
'machine learning course',
'machine learning class',
],
//Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext)
link: 'linktext',
},
};
//Articles to skip
let articleIdsToSkip = ['post-2651', 'post-3414', 'post-3540'];
//keyword with its related achortag is recieved here along with article id
function searchAndReplace(keyword, anchorTag, articleId) {
//selects the h3 h4 and p tags that are inside of the article
let content = document.querySelector(`#${articleId} .entry-content`);
//replaces the "linktext" in achor tag with the keyword that will be searched and replaced
let newLink = anchorTag.replace('linktext', keyword);
//regular expression to search keyword
var re = new RegExp('(' + keyword + ')', 'g');
//this replaces the keywords in h3 h4 and p tags content with achor tag
content.innerHTML = content.innerHTML.replace(re, newLink);
}
function articleFilter(keyword, anchorTag) {
//gets all the articles
var articles = document.querySelectorAll('article');
//if its zero or less then there are no articles
if (articles.length > 0) {
for (let x = 0; x < articles.length; x++) {
//articles to skip is an array in which there are ids of articles which should not get effected
//if the current article's id is also in that array then do not call search and replace with its data
if (!articleIdsToSkip.includes(articles[x].id)) {
//search and replace is called on articles which should get effected
searchAndReplace(keyword, anchorTag, articles[x].id, key);
} else {
console.log(
`Cannot replace the keywords in article with id ${articles[x].id}`
);
}
}
} else {
console.log('No articles found.');
}
}
let key; //not part of script, added
for (key in keywordsAndLinks) {
//key is the object in keywords and links object i.e ds, ml, ai
for (let i = 0; i < keywordsAndLinks[key].keywords.length; i++) {
//keywordsAndLinks[key].keywords is the array of keywords for key (ds, ml, ai)
//keywordsAndLinks[key].keywords[i] is the keyword and keywordsAndLinks[key].link is the link
//keyword and link is sent to searchreplace where it is then replaced using regular expression and replace function
articleFilter(
keywordsAndLinks[key].keywords[i],
keywordsAndLinks[key].link
);
}
}
function cleanLinks() {
// (making smal functions is for DRY) this function gets the links and only keeps the first 2 and from the rest removes the anchor tag and replaces it with its text
function removeLinks(links) {
if (links.length > 1) {
for (let i = 2; i < links.length; i++) {
links[i].outerHTML = links[i].textContent;
}
}
}
//arrays which will contain all the achor tags found with the class (ds-link, ml-link, ailink) in each article inserted using search and replace
let dslinks;
let mllinks;
let ailinks;
let nllinks;
let deslinks;
let tdlinks;
let iaslinks;
let llinks;
let pbplinks;
let mlclinks;
const content = document.querySelectorAll('article'); //all articles
content.forEach((c) => {
//to skip the articles with specific ids
if (!articleIdsToSkip.includes(c.id)) {
//getting all the anchor tags in each article one by one
dslinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.ds-link`);
mllinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.ml-link`);
ailinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.ai-link`);
nllinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.ntrl-link`);
deslinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.des-link`);
tdlinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.td-link`);
iaslinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.ias-link`);
mlclinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.mlc-link`);
llinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.l-link`);
pbplinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.pbp-link`);
//sending the anchor tags list of each article one by one to remove extra anchor tags
removeLinks(dslinks);
removeLinks(mllinks);
removeLinks(ailinks);
removeLinks(nllinks);
removeLinks(deslinks);
removeLinks(tdlinks);
removeLinks(iaslinks);
removeLinks(mlclinks);
removeLinks(llinks);
removeLinks(pbplinks);
}
});
}
//To remove extra achor tags of each category (ds, ml, ai) and only have 2 of each category per article
cleanLinks();
*/
//Recommended Articles
var ctaLinks = [
/*
' ' +
'
Towards AI has published Building LLMs for Production—our 470+ page guide to mastering LLMs with practical projects and expert insights!
' +
'' +
'' +
'' +
'
Note: Content contains the views of the contributing authors and not Towards AI. Disclosure: This website may contain sponsored content and affiliate links.
Towards AI has built a jobs board tailored specifically to Machine Learning and Data Science Jobs and Skills. Our software searches for live AI jobs each hour, labels and categorises them and makes them easily searchable. Explore over 10,000 live jobs today with Towards AI Jobs!
Join thousands of data leaders on the AI newsletter. It’s free, we don’t spam, and we never share your email address. Keep up to date with the latest work in AI. From research to projects and ideas. If you are building an AI startup, an AI-related product, or a service, we invite you to consider becoming a sponsor.