Name: Towards AI Legal Name: Towards AI, Inc. Description: Towards AI is the world's leading artificial intelligence (AI) and technology publication. Read by thought-leaders and decision-makers around the world. Phone Number: +1-650-246-9381 Email: pub@towardsai.net
228 Park Avenue South New York, NY 10003 United States
Website: Publisher: https://towardsai.net/#publisher Diversity Policy: https://towardsai.net/about Ethics Policy: https://towardsai.net/about Masthead: https://towardsai.net/about
Name: Towards AI Legal Name: Towards AI, Inc. Description: Towards AI is the world's leading artificial intelligence (AI) and technology publication. Founders: Roberto Iriondo, , Job Title: Co-founder and Advisor Works for: Towards AI, Inc. Follow Roberto: X, LinkedIn, GitHub, Google Scholar, Towards AI Profile, Medium, ML@CMU, FreeCodeCamp, Crunchbase, Bloomberg, Roberto Iriondo, Generative AI Lab, Generative AI Lab Denis Piffaretti, Job Title: Co-founder Works for: Towards AI, Inc. Louie Peters, Job Title: Co-founder Works for: Towards AI, Inc. Louis-François Bouchard, Job Title: Co-founder Works for: Towards AI, Inc. Cover:
Towards AI Cover
Logo:
Towards AI Logo
Areas Served: Worldwide Alternate Name: Towards AI, Inc. Alternate Name: Towards AI Co. Alternate Name: towards ai Alternate Name: towardsai Alternate Name: towards.ai Alternate Name: tai Alternate Name: toward ai Alternate Name: toward.ai Alternate Name: Towards AI, Inc. Alternate Name: towardsai.net Alternate Name: pub.towardsai.net
5 stars – based on 497 reviews

Frequently Used, Contextual References

TODO: Remember to copy unique IDs whenever it needs used. i.e., URL: 304b2e42315e

Resources

Take our 85+ lesson From Beginner to Advanced LLM Developer Certification: From choosing a project to deploying a working product this is the most comprehensive and practical LLM course out there!

Publication

Evaluating Synthetic Data using Machine Learning
Latest

Evaluating Synthetic Data using Machine Learning

Last Updated on January 7, 2023 by Editorial Team

Author(s): Varatharajah Vaseekaran

Originally published on Towards AI the World’s Leading AI and Technology News and Media Company. If you are building an AI-related product or service, we invite you to consider becoming an AI sponsor. At Towards AI, we help scale AI and technology startups. Let us help you unleash your technology to the masses.

Evaluating Synthetic Data Using Machine Learning

Adversarial validation to evaluate synthetic data

“Poor accuracy score” is a phrase that might cause nightmares for many data science professionals when building machine learning models for classification problems. However, a poor accuracy score can be a blessing in rare scenarios, especially when performing adversarial validation.

Adversarial validation is conducted to evaluate if two datasets come from the same distribution or not. Generally, it is used to measure data shifts in training and test sets used in a machine learning problem. Similarly, adversarial validation can be used to evaluate the quality of the synthetic data.

Photo by Miikka Luotio on Unsplash

Synthetic Data: An Overview

In simple terms, synthetic data are artificially generated data that mathematically and statistically represent real-world data. Synthetic data are created using algorithms (e.g., SMOTE, ADASYN, Variational Autoencoders, GANs, etc.) and can be used as a substitute for real-world data when performing data analysis and building machine learning models.

Synthetic data enables data privacy, as it masks sensitive information, and therefore, synthetic data is invaluable in the financial and medical sectors. Synthetic data also saves the cost and human labor needed to gather, process, and label massive datasets, as a few well-labeled data can be used to generate mounds of synthetic data.

Since there are many ways to generate synthetic data, there needs to be a proper evaluation method to measure the quality of synthetic data relative to real-world data. For such evaluation, this article focuses on adversarial validation.

You can get more insights on synthetic data and on how to generate synthetic data using powerful and open-sourced GAN implementations by referring to this article:

GANs for Synthetic Data Generation

Introduction to Adversarial Validation

Photo by Agence Olloweb on Unsplash

Machine learning has many exciting and innovative applications: from detecting cats and dogs to accurately highlighting tumors in MRI images. In this article, we’ll have a look at how machine learning can be used to determine the similarities between two datasets, i.e., adversarial validation.

The theory behind adversarial validation is quite simple: a classification model is trained to distinguish between two datasets, i.e., the train and test sets. Labels are created for each data, indicating whether the data is from the train set or not, and the new labels are used as targets for training the model.

In a general classification problem, high accuracy indicates the model is performing well. But for adversarial validation, a lower accuracy score indicates better performance. A lower accuracy score means that the model is having problems distinguishing between the two classes of data (from the training set or not). It shows that the distribution of the train set and the test set are similar to each other. If high accuracy is obtained, the model has no problems in distinguishing between the train and the test set, therefore, it can be concluded that both the train and test set have different distributions.

Evaluating Synthetic Data with Adversarial Validation

Adversarial validation can be used to determine the quality of the synthetic data as well. Instead of using a train and test set, the real data and the synthetic data are used to train a machine-learning model. If the model performs poorly, it indicates that the synthetic data and the real data have similar properties, and if the model performs exceptionally well, then it shows that the real data and the synthetic data are completely different from each other.

For this experiment, the popular algorithm that is used for generating synthetic data, SMOTE (Synthetic Minority Over-sampling Technique), is used, and the generated data, together with the real data, would be used to train the model.

The Nearest Earth Objects dataset is used to train the model. A relatively simple dataset comprising details of the diameter, distance from Earth, miss distance, etc., of asteroids that are verified by NASA. Each asteroid is labeled whether it’s hazardous to Earth, and only the hazardous asteroids are considered for this experiment.

Initially, the data is loaded, and the unnecessary fields of the data are removed.

Since all the features of the data are numerical, RobustScaler is used to scale the data.

The pre-processed data is used to generate synthetic data. The minority data (that is, the hazardous asteroids) are used to generate synthetic data using SMOTE. After generating synthetic data, the non-hazardous asteroids are removed.

Now the hazardous label is removed, and a separate data frame is created, which consists only of the synthetic data.

A new label (is_synth) is created for the real data, which consists only of hazardous asteroids, and the synthetic data. This label indicates whether a particular row of data is synthetic or not. Then, both the synthetic and real data are merged to create the final training data.

After creating the final data, the data is split to train and test sets, scaled, and then a classifier is trained on the training set. LightGBM model, a powerful Gradient Boosting model library, is selected as the classification model. Once the model is trained, the test set is used to evaluate the performance of the model.

The model is performing with an accuracy of 68.67%. This indicates that the model is having some trouble classifying which data is synthetic or real. Therefore, it can be concluded that the SMOTE algorithm is working well for hazardous asteroid data in generating synthetic examples.

The repository for the workings of this article can be found here.

Final Words

In the current data-centric AI development, synthetic data is of utmost importance. There are many tools and libraries available to generate synthetic data. However, evaluating the quality of the generated data can be problematic, and this can be solved by performing adversarial validation.

Adversarial validation is generally performed to evaluate the data shift between the training data and the data at inference. This article provides a practical implementation of using adversarial validation to determine the quality of the synthetic data with respect to the real data.

We build a machine-learning classification model using synthetic data and real data. New labels are created for the data, stating whether a particular data is synthetic or not. During the evaluation, if the model performs well (having a high score), it means that the model can clearly separate the real and synthetic data. Therefore the synthetic data is different compared to the real data, and if the model has a poor score, it can be concluded that the synthetic data and the real data are similar.

I hope you have learned a relatively simple method to evaluate synthetic data. I hope you enjoyed the article, and I would love to hear your feedback about this article, as it would help me to improve. Cheers!


Evaluating Synthetic Data using Machine Learning was originally published in Towards AI on Medium, where people are continuing the conversation by highlighting and responding to this story.

Join thousands of data leaders on the AI newsletter. It’s free, we don’t spam, and we never share your email address. Keep up to date with the latest work in AI. From research to projects and ideas. If you are building an AI startup, an AI-related product, or a service, we invite you to consider becoming a sponsor.

Published via Towards AI

Feedback ↓

Sign Up for the Course
`; } else { console.error('Element with id="subscribe" not found within the page with class "home".'); } } }); // Remove duplicate text from articles /* Backup: 09/11/24 function removeDuplicateText() { const elements = document.querySelectorAll('h1, h2, h3, h4, h5, strong'); // Select the desired elements const seenTexts = new Set(); // A set to keep track of seen texts const tagCounters = {}; // Object to track instances of each tag elements.forEach(el => { const tagName = el.tagName.toLowerCase(); // Get the tag name (e.g., 'h1', 'h2', etc.) // Initialize a counter for each tag if not already done if (!tagCounters[tagName]) { tagCounters[tagName] = 0; } // Only process the first 10 elements of each tag type if (tagCounters[tagName] >= 2) { return; // Skip if the number of elements exceeds 10 } const text = el.textContent.trim(); // Get the text content const words = text.split(/\s+/); // Split the text into words if (words.length >= 4) { // Ensure at least 4 words const significantPart = words.slice(0, 5).join(' '); // Get first 5 words for matching // Check if the text (not the tag) has been seen before if (seenTexts.has(significantPart)) { // console.log('Duplicate found, removing:', el); // Log duplicate el.remove(); // Remove duplicate element } else { seenTexts.add(significantPart); // Add the text to the set } } tagCounters[tagName]++; // Increment the counter for this tag }); } removeDuplicateText(); */ // Remove duplicate text from articles function removeDuplicateText() { const elements = document.querySelectorAll('h1, h2, h3, h4, h5, strong'); // Select the desired elements const seenTexts = new Set(); // A set to keep track of seen texts const tagCounters = {}; // Object to track instances of each tag // List of classes to be excluded const excludedClasses = ['medium-author', 'post-widget-title']; elements.forEach(el => { // Skip elements with any of the excluded classes if (excludedClasses.some(cls => el.classList.contains(cls))) { return; // Skip this element if it has any of the excluded classes } const tagName = el.tagName.toLowerCase(); // Get the tag name (e.g., 'h1', 'h2', etc.) // Initialize a counter for each tag if not already done if (!tagCounters[tagName]) { tagCounters[tagName] = 0; } // Only process the first 10 elements of each tag type if (tagCounters[tagName] >= 10) { return; // Skip if the number of elements exceeds 10 } const text = el.textContent.trim(); // Get the text content const words = text.split(/\s+/); // Split the text into words if (words.length >= 4) { // Ensure at least 4 words const significantPart = words.slice(0, 5).join(' '); // Get first 5 words for matching // Check if the text (not the tag) has been seen before if (seenTexts.has(significantPart)) { // console.log('Duplicate found, removing:', el); // Log duplicate el.remove(); // Remove duplicate element } else { seenTexts.add(significantPart); // Add the text to the set } } tagCounters[tagName]++; // Increment the counter for this tag }); } removeDuplicateText(); //Remove unnecessary text in blog excerpts document.querySelectorAll('.blog p').forEach(function(paragraph) { // Replace the unwanted text pattern for each paragraph paragraph.innerHTML = paragraph.innerHTML .replace(/Author\(s\): [\w\s]+ Originally published on Towards AI\.?/g, '') // Removes 'Author(s): XYZ Originally published on Towards AI' .replace(/This member-only story is on us\. Upgrade to access all of Medium\./g, ''); // Removes 'This member-only story...' }); //Load ionic icons and cache them if ('localStorage' in window && window['localStorage'] !== null) { const cssLink = 'https://code.ionicframework.com/ionicons/2.0.1/css/ionicons.min.css'; const storedCss = localStorage.getItem('ionicons'); if (storedCss) { loadCSS(storedCss); } else { fetch(cssLink).then(response => response.text()).then(css => { localStorage.setItem('ionicons', css); loadCSS(css); }); } } function loadCSS(css) { const style = document.createElement('style'); style.innerHTML = css; document.head.appendChild(style); } //Remove elements from imported content automatically function removeStrongFromHeadings() { const elements = document.querySelectorAll('h1, h2, h3, h4, h5, h6, span'); elements.forEach(el => { const strongTags = el.querySelectorAll('strong'); strongTags.forEach(strongTag => { while (strongTag.firstChild) { strongTag.parentNode.insertBefore(strongTag.firstChild, strongTag); } strongTag.remove(); }); }); } removeStrongFromHeadings(); "use strict"; window.onload = () => { /* //This is an object for each category of subjects and in that there are kewords and link to the keywods let keywordsAndLinks = { //you can add more categories and define their keywords and add a link ds: { keywords: [ //you can add more keywords here they are detected and replaced with achor tag automatically 'data science', 'Data science', 'Data Science', 'data Science', 'DATA SCIENCE', ], //we will replace the linktext with the keyword later on in the code //you can easily change links for each category here //(include class="ml-link" and linktext) link: 'linktext', }, ml: { keywords: [ //Add more keywords 'machine learning', 'Machine learning', 'Machine Learning', 'machine Learning', 'MACHINE LEARNING', ], //Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext) link: 'linktext', }, ai: { keywords: [ 'artificial intelligence', 'Artificial intelligence', 'Artificial Intelligence', 'artificial Intelligence', 'ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE', ], //Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext) link: 'linktext', }, nl: { keywords: [ 'NLP', 'nlp', 'natural language processing', 'Natural Language Processing', 'NATURAL LANGUAGE PROCESSING', ], //Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext) link: 'linktext', }, des: { keywords: [ 'data engineering services', 'Data Engineering Services', 'DATA ENGINEERING SERVICES', ], //Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext) link: 'linktext', }, td: { keywords: [ 'training data', 'Training Data', 'training Data', 'TRAINING DATA', ], //Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext) link: 'linktext', }, ias: { keywords: [ 'image annotation services', 'Image annotation services', 'image Annotation services', 'image annotation Services', 'Image Annotation Services', 'IMAGE ANNOTATION SERVICES', ], //Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext) link: 'linktext', }, l: { keywords: [ 'labeling', 'labelling', ], //Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext) link: 'linktext', }, pbp: { keywords: [ 'previous blog posts', 'previous blog post', 'latest', ], //Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext) link: 'linktext', }, mlc: { keywords: [ 'machine learning course', 'machine learning class', ], //Change your article link (include class="ml-link" and linktext) link: 'linktext', }, }; //Articles to skip let articleIdsToSkip = ['post-2651', 'post-3414', 'post-3540']; //keyword with its related achortag is recieved here along with article id function searchAndReplace(keyword, anchorTag, articleId) { //selects the h3 h4 and p tags that are inside of the article let content = document.querySelector(`#${articleId} .entry-content`); //replaces the "linktext" in achor tag with the keyword that will be searched and replaced let newLink = anchorTag.replace('linktext', keyword); //regular expression to search keyword var re = new RegExp('(' + keyword + ')', 'g'); //this replaces the keywords in h3 h4 and p tags content with achor tag content.innerHTML = content.innerHTML.replace(re, newLink); } function articleFilter(keyword, anchorTag) { //gets all the articles var articles = document.querySelectorAll('article'); //if its zero or less then there are no articles if (articles.length > 0) { for (let x = 0; x < articles.length; x++) { //articles to skip is an array in which there are ids of articles which should not get effected //if the current article's id is also in that array then do not call search and replace with its data if (!articleIdsToSkip.includes(articles[x].id)) { //search and replace is called on articles which should get effected searchAndReplace(keyword, anchorTag, articles[x].id, key); } else { console.log( `Cannot replace the keywords in article with id ${articles[x].id}` ); } } } else { console.log('No articles found.'); } } let key; //not part of script, added for (key in keywordsAndLinks) { //key is the object in keywords and links object i.e ds, ml, ai for (let i = 0; i < keywordsAndLinks[key].keywords.length; i++) { //keywordsAndLinks[key].keywords is the array of keywords for key (ds, ml, ai) //keywordsAndLinks[key].keywords[i] is the keyword and keywordsAndLinks[key].link is the link //keyword and link is sent to searchreplace where it is then replaced using regular expression and replace function articleFilter( keywordsAndLinks[key].keywords[i], keywordsAndLinks[key].link ); } } function cleanLinks() { // (making smal functions is for DRY) this function gets the links and only keeps the first 2 and from the rest removes the anchor tag and replaces it with its text function removeLinks(links) { if (links.length > 1) { for (let i = 2; i < links.length; i++) { links[i].outerHTML = links[i].textContent; } } } //arrays which will contain all the achor tags found with the class (ds-link, ml-link, ailink) in each article inserted using search and replace let dslinks; let mllinks; let ailinks; let nllinks; let deslinks; let tdlinks; let iaslinks; let llinks; let pbplinks; let mlclinks; const content = document.querySelectorAll('article'); //all articles content.forEach((c) => { //to skip the articles with specific ids if (!articleIdsToSkip.includes(c.id)) { //getting all the anchor tags in each article one by one dslinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.ds-link`); mllinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.ml-link`); ailinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.ai-link`); nllinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.ntrl-link`); deslinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.des-link`); tdlinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.td-link`); iaslinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.ias-link`); mlclinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.mlc-link`); llinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.l-link`); pbplinks = document.querySelectorAll(`#${c.id} .entry-content a.pbp-link`); //sending the anchor tags list of each article one by one to remove extra anchor tags removeLinks(dslinks); removeLinks(mllinks); removeLinks(ailinks); removeLinks(nllinks); removeLinks(deslinks); removeLinks(tdlinks); removeLinks(iaslinks); removeLinks(mlclinks); removeLinks(llinks); removeLinks(pbplinks); } }); } //To remove extra achor tags of each category (ds, ml, ai) and only have 2 of each category per article cleanLinks(); */ //Recommended Articles var ctaLinks = [ /* ' ' + '

Subscribe to our AI newsletter!

' + */ '

Take our 85+ lesson From Beginner to Advanced LLM Developer Certification: From choosing a project to deploying a working product this is the most comprehensive and practical LLM course out there!

'+ '

Towards AI has published Building LLMs for Production—our 470+ page guide to mastering LLMs with practical projects and expert insights!

' + '
' + '' + '' + '

Note: Content contains the views of the contributing authors and not Towards AI.
Disclosure: This website may contain sponsored content and affiliate links.

' + 'Discover Your Dream AI Career at Towards AI Jobs' + '

Towards AI has built a jobs board tailored specifically to Machine Learning and Data Science Jobs and Skills. Our software searches for live AI jobs each hour, labels and categorises them and makes them easily searchable. Explore over 10,000 live jobs today with Towards AI Jobs!

' + '
' + '

🔥 Recommended Articles 🔥

' + 'Why Become an LLM Developer? Launching Towards AI’s New One-Stop Conversion Course'+ 'Testing Launchpad.sh: A Container-based GPU Cloud for Inference and Fine-tuning'+ 'The Top 13 AI-Powered CRM Platforms
' + 'Top 11 AI Call Center Software for 2024
' + 'Learn Prompting 101—Prompt Engineering Course
' + 'Explore Leading Cloud Providers for GPU-Powered LLM Training
' + 'Best AI Communities for Artificial Intelligence Enthusiasts
' + 'Best Workstations for Deep Learning
' + 'Best Laptops for Deep Learning
' + 'Best Machine Learning Books
' + 'Machine Learning Algorithms
' + 'Neural Networks Tutorial
' + 'Best Public Datasets for Machine Learning
' + 'Neural Network Types
' + 'NLP Tutorial
' + 'Best Data Science Books
' + 'Monte Carlo Simulation Tutorial
' + 'Recommender System Tutorial
' + 'Linear Algebra for Deep Learning Tutorial
' + 'Google Colab Introduction
' + 'Decision Trees in Machine Learning
' + 'Principal Component Analysis (PCA) Tutorial
' + 'Linear Regression from Zero to Hero
'+ '

', /* + '

Join thousands of data leaders on the AI newsletter. It’s free, we don’t spam, and we never share your email address. Keep up to date with the latest work in AI. From research to projects and ideas. If you are building an AI startup, an AI-related product, or a service, we invite you to consider becoming a sponsor.

',*/ ]; var replaceText = { '': '', '': '', '
': '
' + ctaLinks + '
', }; Object.keys(replaceText).forEach((txtorig) => { //txtorig is the key in replacetext object const txtnew = replaceText[txtorig]; //txtnew is the value of the key in replacetext object let entryFooter = document.querySelector('article .entry-footer'); if (document.querySelectorAll('.single-post').length > 0) { //console.log('Article found.'); const text = entryFooter.innerHTML; entryFooter.innerHTML = text.replace(txtorig, txtnew); } else { // console.log('Article not found.'); //removing comment 09/04/24 } }); var css = document.createElement('style'); css.type = 'text/css'; css.innerHTML = '.post-tags { display:none !important } .article-cta a { font-size: 18px; }'; document.body.appendChild(css); //Extra //This function adds some accessibility needs to the site. function addAlly() { // In this function JQuery is replaced with vanilla javascript functions const imgCont = document.querySelector('.uw-imgcont'); imgCont.setAttribute('aria-label', 'AI news, latest developments'); imgCont.title = 'AI news, latest developments'; imgCont.rel = 'noopener'; document.querySelector('.page-mobile-menu-logo a').title = 'Towards AI Home'; document.querySelector('a.social-link').rel = 'noopener'; document.querySelector('a.uw-text').rel = 'noopener'; document.querySelector('a.uw-w-branding').rel = 'noopener'; document.querySelector('.blog h2.heading').innerHTML = 'Publication'; const popupSearch = document.querySelector$('a.btn-open-popup-search'); popupSearch.setAttribute('role', 'button'); popupSearch.title = 'Search'; const searchClose = document.querySelector('a.popup-search-close'); searchClose.setAttribute('role', 'button'); searchClose.title = 'Close search page'; // document // .querySelector('a.btn-open-popup-search') // .setAttribute( // 'href', // 'https://medium.com/towards-artificial-intelligence/search' // ); } // Add external attributes to 302 sticky and editorial links function extLink() { // Sticky 302 links, this fuction opens the link we send to Medium on a new tab and adds a "noopener" rel to them var stickyLinks = document.querySelectorAll('.grid-item.sticky a'); for (var i = 0; i < stickyLinks.length; i++) { /* stickyLinks[i].setAttribute('target', '_blank'); stickyLinks[i].setAttribute('rel', 'noopener'); */ } // Editorial 302 links, same here var editLinks = document.querySelectorAll( '.grid-item.category-editorial a' ); for (var i = 0; i < editLinks.length; i++) { editLinks[i].setAttribute('target', '_blank'); editLinks[i].setAttribute('rel', 'noopener'); } } // Add current year to copyright notices document.getElementById( 'js-current-year' ).textContent = new Date().getFullYear(); // Call functions after page load extLink(); //addAlly(); setTimeout(function() { //addAlly(); //ideally we should only need to run it once ↑ }, 5000); }; function closeCookieDialog (){ document.getElementById("cookie-consent").style.display = "none"; return false; } setTimeout ( function () { closeCookieDialog(); }, 15000); console.log(`%c 🚀🚀🚀 ███ █████ ███████ █████████ ███████████ █████████████ ███████████████ ███████ ███████ ███████ ┌───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │ │ │ Towards AI is looking for contributors! │ │ Join us in creating awesome AI content. │ │ Let's build the future of AI together → │ │ https://towardsai.net/contribute │ │ │ └───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘ `, `background: ; color: #00adff; font-size: large`); //Remove latest category across site document.querySelectorAll('a[rel="category tag"]').forEach(function(el) { if (el.textContent.trim() === 'Latest') { // Remove the two consecutive spaces (  ) if (el.nextSibling && el.nextSibling.nodeValue.includes('\u00A0\u00A0')) { el.nextSibling.nodeValue = ''; // Remove the spaces } el.style.display = 'none'; // Hide the element } }); // Add cross-domain measurement, anonymize IPs 'use strict'; //var ga = gtag; ga('config', 'G-9D3HKKFV1Q', 'auto', { /*'allowLinker': true,*/ 'anonymize_ip': true/*, 'linker': { 'domains': [ 'medium.com/towards-artificial-intelligence', 'datasets.towardsai.net', 'rss.towardsai.net', 'feed.towardsai.net', 'contribute.towardsai.net', 'members.towardsai.net', 'pub.towardsai.net', 'news.towardsai.net' ] } */ }); ga('send', 'pageview'); -->