AI Agents vs. Agentic Systems: Is Your AI Just an Agent?

Author(s): Mohsin Khan

Originally published on Towards AI.

Introduction

Generative AI has revolutionized how we automate processes, make decisions and execute tasks. Within this revolution, the development of autonomous systems like AI agents and Agentic Systems has become increasingly prominent.
While both strive for autonomy and reduced human intervention, their ability to adapt, make decisions and operate in uncertain environments vary significantly.
This article aims to demystify the key differences between AI agents and Agentic systems, outline their respective use cases and provide practical examples to help you determine when your system can truly be considered agentic — even if it already utilizes agents.

The Assistant vs. The Manager Analogy

To illustrate the difference, consider this scenario:
Imagine you’re organizing a large event with two team members:

🔸 Person 1 strictly follows instructions — they’ll set up tables, arrange chairs and position speakers exactly as told. If unexpected guests arrive, they won’t know how to adjust unless you provide further instructions.
🔸Person 2 not only follows instructions but also adapts when things change. If additional guests arrive, they’ll arrange extra seating without being told. If the sound system fails, they’ll find an alternative solution.

In this analogy:
🔹 Person 1 behaves like an AI Agent — a system that follows predefined rules or models to complete specific tasks.
🔹 Person 2 mirrors an Agentic System — a system capable of dynamic decision-making, learning from new data and modifying strategies based on evolving conditions.
This fundamental difference — adaptability — determines whether your system can be called agentic.

A more sophisticated example

Imagine two individuals handling a critical business task:

🔹 Person 1 — The Assistant (AI Agent):

Imagine Person 1 is an assistant tasked with preparing a financial forecast. You provide precise instructions:

Pull last quarter’s sales data
Generate a trend analysis report
Email the report to leadership by 3 PM

If the sales data is incomplete or a senior executive requests additional insights, Person 1 halts — waiting for further instructions.

🔹 Person 2 — The Manager (Agentic System):

Now imagine Person 2, a proactive manager. You assign them the broader goal:

Prepare a comprehensive financial forecast for leadership

Instead of following rigid steps, this person adapts:
If sales data is incomplete, they’ll merge data from other sources.
If leadership asks for an alternative projection model, they’ll switch methods.
If the deadline moves up, they’ll prioritize critical insights over secondary details.

What is an AI Agent?

An AI Agent is an autonomous system designed to execute well-defined tasks based on instructions, rules or models.
These agents typically:
🔹 Follow predefined logic
🔹 Excel in structured, predictable environments
🔹 Deliver consistent outputs for repetitive tasks
🔹 Operate effectively when outcomes are stable

Key Characteristics of AI Agents:

1. Rule-Based Execution: Operates within a fixed logic framework.
2. Limited Adaptability: Struggles with unpredictable or dynamic conditions.
3. Task-Focused: Specializes in isolated, specific tasks.

Examples of AI Agents in Action:

1. Automated Credit Scoring System: Uses predefined rules to evaluate loan applications but cannot assess alternative credit indicators.
2. Logistics Routing Algorithm: Plans delivery routes based on static traffic patterns but struggles during real-time traffic disruptions.
3. Stock Market Trading Bot: Executes trades based on predefined technical indicators but fails to adjust when unexpected geopolitical events impact the market.
4. Customer Support Email Classifier: Categorizes emails by topic but cannot interpret emotionally charged or complex requests.
5. Document Review System: Flags compliance risks in contracts but cannot identify emerging legal trends unless explicitly programmed.

What is an Agentic System?

An Agentic System is an advanced system capable of adjusting its behaviour based on changing inputs, unexpected conditions or evolving goals. These systems go beyond executing predefined steps.
They actively:
🔸 Adapt to real-time changes and dynamic conditions
🔸 Evaluate multiple options and make informed decisions
🔸 Learn from feedback to improve future performance
🔸 Manage ambiguity by adjusting strategies when required

Key Characteristics of Agentic Systems:

1. Decision-Making Capability: Makes independent choices in complex situations.
2. Context Awareness: Recognizes patterns, identifies risks and adjusts behaviour accordingly.
3. Learning & Improvement: Continuously refines itself using feedback or new data.

💡How do Agentic systems learn continuously :

An Agentic System achieves continuous learning by constantly adapting its decision-making based on real-world interactions. They refine their behavior through feedback loops, self-reflection, real-time knowledge retrieval and human-in-the-loop adjustments. They leverage techniques like reinforcement learning, adaptive memory, meta-learning, etc., to evolve over time.

Examples of Agentic Systems in Action:

1. Autonomous Portfolio Manager: Continuously adjusts investment strategies in response to economic shifts, sector trends and investor preferences.
2. Dynamic Supply Chain Optimizer: Re-routes shipments automatically based on weather, strikes or supplier delays, prioritizing high-demand products.
3. Advanced Fraud Detection System: Learns from evolving fraud patterns, detecting complex schemes without manual rule updates.
4. AI-Driven Medical Diagnosis System: Combines patient history, new symptoms and emerging medical research to recommend personalized treatment plans.
5. Smart Incident Response System: Detects cyber threats, prioritizes risks and autonomously mitigates attacks by isolating infected systems and re-routing network traffic.

When Does an AI System Become Agentic?

Even if your system uses AI agents, it qualifies as agentic only if it demonstrates the following behaviors:

🔸 Adaptive Decision-Making: It actively adjusts its behavior when the environment changes.
🔸 Goal-Oriented Flexibility: It redefines objectives based on evolving requirements.
🔸 Continuous Learning: It refines its decision-making through experience.
🔸 Uncertainty Management: It handles unpredictable scenarios without extensive human input.

Contrast in Examples: AI Agents vs. Agentic Systems

🔵 AI Agents (Predictable Task Automation)

These systems excel in following predefined rules but lack adaptability in dynamic situations.

1. Weather Forecast App for Agriculture: Provides farmers with a fixed 7-day forecast but cannot recommend alternative planting or harvesting schedules when unexpected weather conditions arise.
2. Auto-Responder for Legal Inquiries: Replies to common legal queries using predefined templates but fails to interpret complex contract-specific concerns.
3. Inventory Scanner in Pharmaceutical Storage: Identifies expired drugs based on printed dates but cannot detect missing labels or temperature-damaged items unless explicitly instructed.
4. Fitness Tracker for Endurance Athletes: Tracks heart rate and calories but cannot adjust pacing strategies or recommend recovery plans during unexpected fatigue.
5. Automated Flight Booking System: Suggests flights based on fixed rules like departure time and price but cannot anticipate and recommend alternative routes during airline strikes or cancellations.

🔵 Agentic Systems (Adaptive Decision-Making)

These systems go beyond static logic, adjusting strategies to achieve goals in changing environments.

1. Adaptive Crop Advisory System: Uses weather data, soil conditions and market trends to recommend optimal planting times, pest control strategies and harvesting schedules.
2. Intelligent Legal Assistant for Contract Reviews: Analyzes contracts, identifies ambiguous terms and suggests alternative wording based on recent legal precedents.
3. AI-Driven Pharmaceutical Inventory Manager: Predicts potential drug shortages, dynamically reallocates supplies between pharmacies and suggests emergency restocking plans during unexpected demand surges.
4. Smart Fitness Coach for Endurance Athletes: Analyzes workout data, sleep patterns and recovery trends to suggest personalized pacing adjustments and recovery plans during training or competitions.
5. Intelligent Travel Re-Routing System: Tracks real-time airline delays, weather updates and traveler preferences to proactively suggest alternative routes, rebook flights and notify connecting services when disruptions occur.

Checklist ✅ : Is Your System Truly Agentic?

Before labeling your system as agentic, ask yourself:

🔹 Does the system actively modify its strategy based on new data?
🔹 Can it manage unforeseen conditions without manual intervention?
🔹 Does it improve through learning or experience?
🔹 Can it redefine its goals when the situation demands? If your system meets these criteria, it’s likely agentic.

Conclusion:

Labeling a system as agentic when it’s merely rule-driven can create unrealistic expectations. Understanding the distinction between AI Agents and Agentic Systems ensures you design systems that align with business needs, user expectations and long-term scalability. In domains like customer support, network management and personalized learning, the right balance between agents and agentic behavior can significantly impact performance. Curious to know if your system qualifies as agentic? Start by evaluating its adaptability, decision-making power and learning capabilities.

Join thousands of data leaders on the AI newsletter. Join over 80,000 subscribers and keep up to date with the latest developments in AI. From research to projects and ideas. If you are building an AI startup, an AI-related product, or a service, we invite you to consider becoming a sponsor.

Published via Towards AI